Reflection, reflexivity and the ways we make meaning
As coaches and supervisors, we are familiar with the invitation to reflect. To pause, notice, make meaning and learn from our experience.
But what does it mean to be reflexive? And why does the distinction matter?
In our work with coaches and supervisors, we use three metaphors to explore reflective practice.
The crystal ball — looking ahead
Before action, we imagine what might unfold. We anticipate possibilities, consider our intentions and prepare ourselves for what we may encounter.
The mirror — noticing in the moment
During action, we attend to what is happening. We notice ourselves, others and the relationships between us. We make choices and adjust as events unfold.
The rearview mirror — looking back
After action, we revisit our experience. We explore what happened, what surprised us, what we learned and what we might do differently.
These are three ways of reflecting: before, during and after action.
But there is another dimension.
Reflexivity invites us to turn our attention towards the lens through which we are looking.
It asks us to notice how our assumptions, experiences, identities, relationships and positions of power shape what we perceive, how we interpret it and how we participate in what unfolds.
Consider a team coach who experiences a team as resistant.
Reflection might invite them to explore what happened, how they responded and what they could do differently.
Reflexivity invites them to wonder:
- What am I interpreting as resistance?
- What assumptions am I making about how this team should behave?
- How might my expectations or interventions be contributing to what is happening?
- What becomes possible when I see the situation differently?
Reflexivity isn’t confined to the moment of action. We can bring it to our anticipation, our participation and our recollection.
And it isn’t separate from reflection. It deepens reflective practice by making our own ways of seeing available for inquiry.
Sometimes, in becoming curious about the one who is looking, we discover that what we took to be reality was also a way of making meaning. What we once could only see through becomes something we can look at, question and transform.
And then we recognize that we are not the only ones looking.
The team member, the leader, the sponsor, the co-coach and the wider system each bring different ways of seeing. Each notices something, misses something and makes meaning from their own position.
In team coaching supervision, we can become curious about these different perspectives, what they reveal and what happens between them. We discover that what appeared obvious through one lens becomes less certain through another.
This is where new possibilities emerge.
Not simply by seeing more, but by becoming increasingly aware of how our way of seeing shapes what we see — and how our ways of seeing shape one another.
The invitation is not only to look more carefully into the crystal ball, mirror or rearview mirror.
It is to become curious about the one who is looking.
And to ask:
How does my way of seeing shape what I see?
Further reading:
Our earlier exploration of these metaphors, Reflecting on Reflection: The Journey to Coaching Maturity, appeared in choice magazine, Volume 21, Issue 1.
The distinction between reflection-in-action and reflection-on-action draws on Donald Schön’s The Reflective Practitioner(1983). The developmental insight about examining our own meaning-making connects with Robert Kegan’s constructive-developmental work.