What We See, Hold, and Miss

Behind the Scenes of Team Coaching Supervision
Picture of Sherry Matheson

Sherry Matheson

What We See, Hold, and Miss

Something in us recognizes something in them, and shapes what happens next.

I have been thinking a lot about this in my supervision practice, particularly when I am supervising team coaches.

A team coach brings a team into supervision. They tell us about the leader, the sponsor, the conflict, the quiet person, the co-coach, the tension in the room, and what they have tried so far. As supervisors, we listen.

And almost immediately, something catches our attention.

There may be a person we feel drawn toward. Someone we want to protect. Someone we feel frustrated with. There may be a piece of the story that seems especially important to us, even before we fully understand why.

For me, this is one of the most interesting parts of supervision. It reminds me that I am never standing completely outside the system looking in. I am part of what is happening in the supervision room too.

The question is not whether that is good or bad. The question is whether I am aware of it.

Kerry Woodcock and I have been exploring this through three simple words: SEE, HOLD, and MISS.

We are not offering SEE, HOLD, and MISS as another formal model of supervision. We use it as a reflective frame. It helps us slow down and notice how we are positioning ourselves in relation to the system, what we are drawn toward, what we may begin carrying, and what might still be outside our awareness.

For me, these three words create a very simple but powerful invitation:

What am I seeing?

What am I holding?

And what might I still be missing?

 

SEE: What catches my attention?

Imagine a team coach brings the following situation into supervision.

The coach has been working with a senior leadership team for several months. The team has a relatively new leader who was promoted internally, and two other members of the team had also wanted the role.

The team appears polite until difficult decisions need to be made. Then two members regularly challenge one another and the team leader quickly steps in to bring the conversation back under control.

The executive sponsor who commissioned the work has privately told the coach that they expected the team to be further along by now.

One member rarely speaks.

At the same time, the coach and co-coach have started disagreeing about what the team needs. One believes they should work more directly with the conflict. The other is concerned that pushing too hard could damage trust.

The coach comes into supervision and says, “I don’t know what I’m missing. I feel like I’m failing this team.”

What did you notice first?

Did you notice the coach’s sense of failure?

The conflict between the two team members?

The leader shutting down the tension?

The sponsor’s expectation?

The quiet team member?

The disagreement between the co-coaches?

Or did your attention go somewhere else entirely?

What I find so interesting is that we can all hear the same situation and notice something different.

There is no right answer.

What matters is becoming curious about why something became foreground for me while something else stayed in the background.

I have come to understand that what I notice is not neutral. My history, my values, my experience with leadership, conflict, power, responsibility, belonging, loyalty, partnership, and endings all influence the lens I bring.

That does not mean my noticing is wrong. It means it is mine.

For example, one supervisor may immediately notice the quiet team member because they are highly attuned to inclusion and voice. Another may notice the sponsor because they are sensitive to power and contracting. Another may become interested in the coach’s sense of failure because responsibility and performance have strong meaning for them.

The developmental question is not, “Should I have noticed something else?”

For me, the more useful question is, “What does my attention tell me about the lens I am bringing to this supervision?”

Where do I position myself?

I also find it helpful to ask where I have positioned myself in relation to the people in the story.

Am I standing beside the coach?

Do I find myself protecting the quiet team member?

Am I frustrated with the team leader?

Do I feel critical of the sponsor?

Have I already decided which co-coach has the better read on the situation?

Again, none of this needs to be judged. It needs to be noticed.

I believe our positioning matters because it shapes the questions we ask.

If I am standing very close to the coach, I may start to see the sponsor as unreasonable.

If I strongly identify with the quieter voice, I may quickly see the more dominant team members as the problem.

If I have a history of challenging authority, I may be quicker to question the leader.

If conflict feels productive and necessary to me, I may move toward it more quickly than the coach or team is ready for.

If conflict is something I have learned to soften or avoid, I may unconsciously help the coach move away from it.

For me, one of the most useful questions is:

If I am standing beside this person in the system, who am I now looking at from across the room?

That question can be uncomfortable, and I think that is why it matters.

It creates a little more space between what I am noticing and what I am assuming.

Every question privileges something

One of the things I have come to appreciate in supervision is that every question privileges something.

If I ask, “Have you talked to your co-coach about this?” I am privileging action and partnership.

If I ask, “What happens in you when your co-coach softens the tension?” I am privileging the coach’s internal response.

If I ask, “What might your co-coach be noticing that you are not?” I am privileging multiple perspectives.

If I ask, “How might what is happening between you and your co-coach reflect something happening in the team?” I am inviting us to consider parallel process.

None of those questions are wrong.

Each one simply takes us somewhere different.

That is why I believe our questions tell us something about us as supervisors. They reveal what we think matters.

They bring something into the foreground and leave something else in the background.

When I remember that, it helps me become less attached to the cleverness of my question and more curious about the direction I am taking the supervision.

 

HOLD: What do I begin carrying?

The second word in the frame is HOLD.

This one has become particularly important for me because there is a difference between holding complexity and carrying responsibility.

As supervisors, we do need to hold.

We hold uncertainty.

We hold multiple truths.

We hold the coach’s experience without rushing to take it away.

We hold the complexity of the team, the organization, the contracting, the relationships, and the wider system.

But sometimes, without realizing it, holding can become carrying.

Imagine again that the coach says, “I feel like I am failing this team.”

What happens in you?

Do you want to reassure them?

Do you start thinking about what intervention they could try next?

Do you want to protect them from the sponsor’s criticism?

Do you feel a pull to restore their confidence?

Do you start working harder than they are to figure out what should happen?

I know that pull. I think many of us do.

For me, the distinction is something like this:

Holding says, “I can stay with this uncertainty with you.”

Carrying says, “I need to make this better for you.”

The shift can be very subtle.

I may know I have crossed from holding into carrying when I become more invested in finding an answer than the coach is, when I feel urgency to reduce their discomfort, when I start solving the team’s problem, or when I feel responsible for whether the coaching engagement succeeds.

At that point I need to ask myself:

What has just become my responsibility that was not my responsibility a few minutes ago?

That question often tells me a lot.

What might be travelling through the system?

Team coaching supervision also reminds me that what we are feeling may not begin with us.

The organization may be under pressure for results.

The sponsor may be carrying that pressure.

The coach may begin to carry the sponsor’s expectation that the team should be further along.

Then the coach arrives in supervision feeling that they are failing.

And now, as supervisor, I may suddenly feel pressure to help the coach find the answer.

Organization.

Sponsor.

Coach.

Supervisor.

The pressure has travelled.

This is where parallel process becomes so useful to me, not as something I need to diagnose, but as something I can become curious about.

What if the pressure I am feeling in supervision is information?

What if my urge to fix is information?

What if my confusion, impatience, protectiveness, or desire to rescue is information?

I do not want to assume that every feeling in me belongs to the system. That would be too simplistic.

But I also do not want to dismiss my own response as irrelevant.

For me, supervision is one of the places where we get to wonder about both.

What belongs to me?

What might belong to the coach?

What might be moving through the wider system?

And what becomes possible when we do not rush to decide?

 

MISS: What remains outside our awareness?

The third word is MISS.

This may be the most humbling one.

No matter how experienced we are, we will miss things.

We cannot see everything.

I do not think the goal is to become the supervisor who sees the whole system perfectly. I am not sure that person exists.

For me, the work is developing enough humility to remember that my first interpretation is always partial.

Perhaps we become so focused on the two people in conflict that we do not ask what function the conflict is serving for the team.

Perhaps we describe the quiet member as disengaged and do not notice that we have turned an observation into an interpretation.

Perhaps we focus on the leader shutting down conflict without asking what that leader has learned about conflict in this organization.

Perhaps we accept the sponsor’s expectation of progress without going back to the contracting and asking how success was defined in the first place.

Perhaps we decide the disagreement between the co-coaches is a problem to solve, rather than wondering whether each coach may be carrying a different part of the team’s tension.

Perhaps we spend the whole supervision conversation helping the coach become more effective and never ask whether team coaching is still the right intervention.

Or perhaps we avoid talking about endings because stopping, changing direction, or recontracting feels too close to failure.

MISS is not an accusation.

It is an invitation.

What have we not yet looked at?

Whose voice is not in the room?

What are we treating as true that we have not actually examined?

What explanation have we become attached to?

What have we made an individual problem that may belong to the wider system?

What might we see if we stood somewhere else?

Something in us recognizes something in them

The phrase I keep coming back to is:

Something in us recognizes something in them, and shapes what happens next.

For me, that is where supervision becomes deeply personal.

We bring our own experience of authority into the room.

We bring our relationship with conflict.

We bring what we have learned about being visible or invisible.

We bring loyalty.

We bring our experiences of partnership, success, failure, responsibility, belonging, and endings.

Some of us learned early to challenge authority.

Some learned to accommodate it.

Some of us are comfortable entering conflict.

Some of us learned that keeping the peace was safer.

Some of us instinctively notice who is being left out.

Some of us take responsibility very quickly.

Some of us find endings relatively straightforward.

For others, letting go carries a very different meaning.

I do not believe this makes us less effective as supervisors.

It makes us human.

The opportunity is to know ourselves well enough that our history does not quietly become the only lens through which we see the coach and the system.

That is why I value supervision so much.

It gives us somewhere to look not only at the coach’s practice, but also at ourselves in relationship to their practice.

The edge of our practice

When we talk about an edge in practice, I think we can sometimes hear it as a deficit.

Something I need to get better at.

Something I should already know.

I see it differently.

For me, an edge is often simply a place where I need to become more conscious.

Perhaps my edge is noticing power.

Perhaps it is staying with conflict a little longer instead of moving too quickly toward resolution.

Perhaps it is resisting my desire to rescue.

Perhaps it is becoming more curious about people whose voices are absent from the story.

Perhaps it is recognizing when I have begun carrying responsibility that belongs to the coach or the system.

Perhaps it is being willing to sit with not knowing.

Perhaps it is allowing the possibility that something needs to change, stop, or end.

I do not think the aim of supervision is to become neutral.

I am not sure we ever are.

I think the invitation is to become increasingly aware of how we position ourselves, what we privilege, what we carry, and what repeatedly sits outside our line of sight.

Clearer sight does not mean seeing everything.

For me, it means becoming more conscious of the lens through which I am looking.

So the next time a coach brings a complex team system into supervision, perhaps we can hold three quiet questions alongside everything else:

What do I SEE?

What am I beginning to HOLD?

What might I still MISS?

And perhaps the most important question underneath all three:

What is happening in me as I sit with what is happening in them?

 

SEE • HOLD • MISS Reflective Frame © 2026 Sherry Matheson & Kerry Woodcock. All rights reserved.

 

 

About the Author

Sherry Matheson, CPCC, ORSCC, PCC, ACTC, EIA-SP, ITCA, ESIA is an executive and leadership coach, team coach, team coaching supervisor, mentor coach, and educator with extensive experience supporting leaders, coaches, and teams in complex relational and organizational systems.

Her work is grounded in a deep belief that who we are shapes how we show up in our coaching and supervision. She is particularly interested in the places where the personal, relational, and systemic meet, and in helping coaches become more aware of what they notice, what they carry, and what may remain outside their awareness.

Sherry is an ICF Professional Certified Coach (PCC) and Advanced Certification in Team Coaching (ACTC) holder, as well as an EMCC-accredited Senior Practitioner, Team Coach, and Coach Supervisor. She is also a Certified Professional Co-Active Coach and an ORSC Certified Coach.

Together with Kerry Woodcock, Sherry co-created the Diploma in Team Coaching Supervision, an internationally accredited program through Novalda, and the SEE • HOLD • MISS Reflective Frame explored in this article.

Subcribe To The Liminal Letter & Reflections Blog

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Scroll to Top